Updated November 2026

Growing Amish paste tomatoes gives you a large, meaty fruit with thick walls and few seeds, which makes it ideal for sauce, canning and roasting. This guide covers how to start the seeds, plant them out, support the vines and keep the fruit sound from first flower to final harvest. Follow these steps and you should get a steady crop of heavy, deep red paste tomatoes from midsummer into fall.

Start Seeds Indoors at the Right Time

Amish paste is an indeterminate variety, and it takes a long season to reach full production. Start seed indoors about 6 to 8 weeks before your last expected frost date. Sow seeds a quarter inch deep in a seed-starting mix, keep the tray at 75 to 85°F, and move seedlings under a grow light or a bright south window as soon as they sprout. For a closer look at container choice and seeding timing, see Seeding Tomatoes for Growing: A Step-by-Step Guide for Beginners.

Shopping for one? See our guide: 3 Best Hanging Containers for Growing Tomatoes in Hanging Containers (2026).

Prepare the Soil and Plant Out

Wait until nights stay above 50°F and the soil has warmed before transplanting. Amish paste does best in loose, well-drained soil with a pH between 6.2 and 6.8. Work compost into the planting area, and if you are using a raised bed, follow the mix guidance in Growing Tomatoes in a Raised Bed: A Step-by-Step Guide for Beginners. Set transplants deep, burying the stem up to the first set of true leaves, and space plants 24 to 36 inches apart so air can move through the canopy.

Support, Water and Feed Consistently

Indeterminate plants can reach 6 feet or more, so install stakes, a cage or a trellis at planting time rather than later. Tie the main stem loosely as it grows, and remove suckers that form in the leaf axils to keep the plant to one or two main stems. Water deeply two to three times a week, delivering about an inch of water at the base rather than on the leaves. Feed with a balanced fertilizer at transplanting, then switch to a lower-nitrogen formula once flowers appear so the plant puts its energy into fruit. Grape Tomatoes Growing Potted: A Step-by-Step Guide for Beginners goes further into this.

Checklist for the Growing Season

  1. Start seed 6 to 8 weeks before last frost.
  2. Harden off seedlings for 7 to 10 days before transplanting.
  3. Plant after soil and night temperatures are reliably warm.
  4. Install support at planting time.
  5. Prune suckers weekly while the plant is actively growing.
  6. Water at the base on a regular schedule.
  7. Check fruit and foliage every few days for pests and disease.

Watch for Common Problems

Blossom end rot, a dark, leathery patch on the bottom of the fruit, usually comes from uneven watering rather than a lack of calcium in the soil. Keep moisture steady with mulch and regular deep watering. Paste tomatoes can also split after heavy rain, which is covered in Why Do Tomatoes Split When Growing? Causes and How to Prevent It. If plants stall in midsummer, check nutrition and soil before assuming a variety problem, as explained in Tomatoes Plants Not Growing: 6 Causes and Fixes That Work.

Common Mistakes

  • Planting too early, which chills seedlings and stunts growth for weeks.
  • Letting suckers grow unchecked, which produces a tangle of foliage and smaller fruit.
  • Watering irregularly, the main trigger for blossom end rot and cracking.
  • Using high-nitrogen fertilizer late in the season, which encourages leaves over fruit.
  • Waiting too long to install a support, which can damage roots and stems when you try to add it later.

A sturdy tomato cage or trellis keeps the heavy indeterminate vines off the ground and makes harvesting easier. View on Amazon

A soil thermometer helps you judge when the ground is warm enough for transplanting. View on Amazon

FAQ

How long does it take Amish paste tomatoes to ripen?

Amish paste is a late-season variety, typically maturing about 80 to 90 days after transplanting, depending on your climate and weather. Fruit usually ripens in late summer.

Do Amish paste tomatoes need a lot of sun?

Yes. Plan for at least 6 to 8 hours of direct sun per day for good fruit set and color.

Can I grow Amish paste tomatoes in a container?

You can, but use a large container, at least 15 to 20 gallons, and expect a smaller harvest than from an in-ground or raised bed plant.

Conclusion

Start seed early, plant out when the soil is warm, and keep watering steady and support strong. With those basics in place, Amish paste tomatoes reward you with large, meaty fruit ideal for sauce. Check your local extension office for timing specific to your area.

Emily Parker

About Emily Parker

Emily Parker is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our vegetable & edible gardening guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.